Health care can never be a basic human right. Basic human rights are something we are born with; that originate from the individual. Like the right to speak freely, to adequately defend yourself from harm, to practice the religion of your choosing, etc. Governments cannot give rights; they can only decide not to take them away...
Health care requires the presence of highly trained professionals willing to exchange their services for what they consider adequate compensation. If the compensation is not adequate they will provide substandard services, move somewhere where adequate compensation is available, or cease to provide these services altogether. When thinking about what passes for a "basic human right" it is helpful to think of the freedoms exercised by prehistoric humans, before modern technology and governments were around to improve standards of living and "civilize" them to make society possible. As a developed and modern society we have decided that it is acceptable to collectively give-up part of our right to the fruits of our labor in exchange for improvements for the common good. Such as, interstate highway systems, armed forces, education, fire protection, and domestic security, but none of these can be considered "basic human rights" because, like health care, they require the willing participation of specialized individuals.
We may well decide that we are willing to further give-up our rights to the fruits of our labors for partial or full health care guarantees, but make no mistake, there will be a net-loss in rights. We better be very sure of the effects our decisions will have on quality of service and any other long-term unintended consequences.
Oh, and by the way, religion has no place in this discussion.
|